CarValidator

2.5i (EJ25, 2009–2011)

20092011 · petrol · 2457cc · 167hp

Engine codes: EJ25, EJ253

History-Dependent

Reliability, common problems and owner reviews for the Subaru Legacy / Outback 2.5i (EJ25, 2009–2011). Check this before you buy used.

The early BM/BR cars used the long-serving EJ25 boxer — torquey and characterful, but carrying the EJ's well-known head-gasket weakness: failures typically start around 160,000 km as a slow external oil or coolant weep, alongside some oil consumption. Not catastrophic if caught early, but a head-gasket job on a boxer is labour-heavy. Condition and history are everything — inspect for weeping gaskets and coolant/oil mixing before buying.

Same engine, other cars

This is the same physical engine (EJ25) sold under different names across brands. Reliability is broadly shared — cross-check these:

Known Issues

Head gasket failurerecurring

EJ25 head gaskets fail ~160k km, usually as a slow external oil/coolant leak; boxer layout makes the job labour-heavy.

Fix / Workaround: Replace both head gaskets (do timing belt + pump same time); pressure-test cooling.

Repair cost: €700–€1800

Typically appears after: 150,000 km

Oil consumptionminor

Some EJ25s use oil with age.

Fix / Workaround: Monitor level; investigate if heavy.

Repair cost: €0–€200

Mileage Thresholds

After 160,000 km: Head-gasket window.

Pre-Purchase Checklist

  • Inspect head gaskets for weeping oil/coolant
  • Check coolant for oil / oil for coolant
  • Timing-belt history (interference)

Frequently asked questions

Is the Subaru Legacy / Outback 2.5i (EJ25, 2009–2011) reliable?

History-Dependent — The early BM/BR cars used the long-serving EJ25 boxer — torquey and characterful, but carrying the EJ's well-known head-gasket weakness: failures typically start around 160,000 km as a slow external oil or coolant weep, alongside some oil consumption. Not catastrophic if caught early, but a head-gasket job on a boxer is labour-heavy. Condition and history are everything — inspect for weeping gaskets and coolant/oil mixing before buying.

What are the common problems and reviews for the Subaru Legacy / Outback 2.5i (EJ25, 2009–2011)?

The most commonly reported problems: Head gasket failure, Oil consumption.

Is a used Subaru Legacy / Outback 2.5i (EJ25, 2009–2011) worth buying?

The engine itself is OK; condition is everything. Unknown or patchy history = walk away.